Black Friday50% off every Pro template and membership with code50% off with Ends in 07days21hrs39min49secShop the sale →

W3 Total Cache vs WP Super Cache: Which One Is Better?

There are numerous factors contributing to the success of a website. Website speed is considered one of the most important factors. Studies show that even if your website has rich and valuable content, if it doesn’t load within seconds, your…

W3 Total Cache vs WP Super Cache: Which one is better?

There are numerous factors contributing to the success of a website. Website speed is considered one of the most important factors. Studies show that even if your website has rich and valuable content, if it doesn’t load within seconds, your visitors will leave your pages immediately. That is why you need the support of WordPress Cache Plugins. Before going over the W3 Total Cache vs WP Super Cache comparison, here is some useful information about using cache plugins on your site.

How are WordPress cache plugins beneficial for your site?

First and foremost, a caching plugin enables your WordPress site to skip some unnecessary steps. Normally, the system has to run the whole page generation process each time a page is accessed, so this process makes your website load slowly. In these cases, the cache plugin will create a copy of the page after loading the page for the first time and then serve the cached version to the next users. Thanks to that, it can minimize the load on your WordPress hosting servers as well as improve user experience on your website.

Additionally, owning a faster website can help you drive organic traffic to your site. In particular, it is a great chance for you to improve your site ranking on Google Search results.

With these advantages in mind, in today’s blog, we will analyze two dominant cache plugins, W3 Total Cache vs WP Super Cache, based on 4 points: main features, ease of setup, price and user ratings. Now, let’s dive into the following section to get insight and make the right decision later.

W3 Total Cache vs WP Super Cache: Introduction

W3 Total Cache

W3 Total Cache

W3 Total Cache is one of the most popular WordPress cache plugins, with tons of positive reviews from users. It is specially designed to maximize website performance and minimize load time. Thanks to that, it is easy for you to improve the SEO and user experience on your site. In addition, it is packed with loads of powerful features including page cache, object cache, limited modification support, and much more.

Besides, this plugin is a complete framework. It not only reduces CPU usage and bandwidth consumption for HTML pages but also handles all aspects that affect your website performance. Another remarkable thing is that it doesn’t require modifications to your theme or your .htaccess.

WP Super Cache

WP Super Cache

Another strong rival of the W3 Total Cache is WP Super Cache developed by Automattic. This plugin also comes with a lot of effective features that you can use to speed up your sites such as gzip compression, page cache, cache preloading, and much more. Additionally, it provides 3 ways to serve cached files: “Expert”, ” Simple” and ” WP-Cache Catching” . Plus, it can sync with your Content Delivery Network, so your site will load faster.

Moreover, it allows you to create static HTML files that your website server is able to showcase to your webpage’s visitors. This is regarded as one of the most effective methods to process WordPress PHP scripts. Further, WP Super Cache also has a simple and lightweight interface, so it only takes a few minutes to install and set up.

Key differences in features

 W3 Total Cache   WP Super Cache
Page Caching  Yes  Yes
Enable CDN  Yes  Yes
 Cache preloading  Yes  Yes
 Minification  Yes  No
 Object / Opcode / Database cache Yes No
 Lazy loading images Yes No
 Set up proxy integration Yes No
 Browser cache Yes No
 Cache Statistics Pro only No

The table shows that both W3 Total Cache and WP Super Cache offer three crucial features to help you improve your website speed effectively: Page Caching, Enable CDN, and Cache Preloading.

In addition to basic features, W3 Total Cache seems to totally overshadow WP Super Cache in terms of diverse features. For example, W3 Total Cache supports reverse proxy integration via Nginx or Varnish. Moreover, it enables modification of posts, pages, inlines, RSS feeds, and much more. Furthermore, this plugin gives you a lot of caching options, from browser caching to fragment and database caching.

Ease of setup

W3 Total Cache

Installing these plugins is similar to installing other plugins. You only need to go to Plugins>Add New and search for W3 Total Cache in the search bar. Then click “ Install Now” and Activate this plugin.

w3 setup 1

After finishing the installation process, go to “Performance” > “General Settings” in your dashboard to enable all functions. Here, a list of options will be displayed, and you can choose a setting for each option, and don’t forget to click “Save All Settings” after making your selections.

w3 setting

WP Super Cache

qvEq7G4 1

The setup process for WP Super Cache is easier compared to the W3 Total Cache. After having installed and activated this plugin, go to “Settings” section>WP Super Cache in the dashboard. You will see a list of 7 tabs including Easy, Advanced, CDN, Contents, Preload, Plugins, and Debug.

Firstly, to set up caching on your site, you must tick the “Caching On” option and Update Status to save the settings.

Secondly, you can enable the caching mode under the “Advanced” tab. Here, there are 2 options to choose from, and Simple Mode is the recommended method. Therefore, you should tick this option instead of choosing Expert mode, since Expert mode requires some complicated editing.

wp setting

=> In short, since W3 Total Cache is packed with more configuration options compared to WP Super Cache, you may encounter some difficulties when setting up this plugin. In our opinion, if you only need a simple tool but still have many vital features, WP Super Cache is more suitable for your site.

Pricing Plans

 Pricing Plan  W3 Total Cache   WP Super Cache
  Free Version   Yes   Yes
 Pro Version  $99/site N/A

As you can see, despite having a lot of powerful features that help you improve your site performance, WP Super Cache is completely free. Therefore, this is really a perfect choice for those who don’t have a big budget but still need an efficient solution.

In contrast, W3 Total Cache comes in 2 versions: the Free version and the Pro version. W3 Total Cache’s free package is also packed with a lot of excellent features. However, if you want to experience more advanced features, the Pro version is a great solution. For that, you have to pay $99/year.

Moreover, when using the W3 Total Cache Pro, you can purchase plenty of specific services and solutions for your plugin such as performance Audit & Consultation, Plugin Configuration, CDN Configuration, and much more. And the costs range from $125 to $250 for each service and solution.

User ratings

Add a heading 1

There is no denying that WP Super Cache has recorded over 2 million installations while W3 Total Cache only has over 1 million installations.

Nevertheless, W3 Total Cache seems to win more users’ hearts than WP Super Cache. The above table shows that W3 Total Cache has 3561 5-star ratings and averages 4,4 out of 5 stars. On the other hand, WP Super Cache has only received 941 5-star ratings and the average rating of this plugin is a little lower, at 4,3/5.

W3 Total Cache Vs WP Super Cache: The final verdict

In general, W3 Total Cache and WP Super Cache are both valuable for your site in various aspects. In our personal view, W3 Total Cache clearly outweighs WP Super Cache in terms of rich features and better performance. Therefore, if you need a powerful tool that meets all your demands, W3 Total Cache is probably a perfect choice.

In contrast, if you only want a basic plugin and have a limited budget, you should consider WP Super Cache for your site. It is not only a cost-effective solution but also a worthwhile cache plugin.

And what is your standpoint? What is your favorite solution? We expect that the battle between W3 Total Cache vs WP Super Cache gives you plenty of valuable knowledge to help you easily choose the right option for your site. If you have any queries and need our assistance, don’t be afraid to leave a comment below.

Moreover, if you want to see other options, check out WordPress Cache Plugin to get more. In addition, check out our tutorial blog if you want to fix a WordPress website not updating quickly.

By the way, if you are going to build a professional website, don’t hesitate to visit our Free WordPress Themes where we offer a lot of eye-catching, modern themes and templates for your website. Best of all, they are fully compatible with the two plugins above.

Build it with a template

Start from a finished design: Joomla templates, WordPress themes or the AI-ready block themes. Every template has a free version and a live demo.

Free download

We'll send the link, setup tips and update notices, and you can reach us anytime through our AI assistant and contact form.

The download starts at once. We email you the link and ask you to confirm your address. Privacy policy.